Last
Updated and Archived July 1, 2004
ACE Conference 2004
Summit 2003: Race and
Cultural Issues on Campus-Issues and Strategies
Resources to assist in dealing with
tragedies and similar events.
|
Free-writing Exercise For Exploring Intense Feelings
What is Free-writing?
Free writing is an informal kind of writing which allows us
to express ourselves freely in the knowledge that nobody will ever see
what we have written. It can be entirely "free", that is, without pre-set
topic, or focused on a topic of the instructor's or writer's choice. For
present purposes, consider using focused freewriting topics; they can
be followed by brief small-group discussions (3-4 persons per group).
Why do Free-writing?
To encourage a writer to focus and articulate, perhaps for
the first time, ideas and feelings about something, in this case the aftermath
of the September 11th tragedies. "Focusing ideas" is a term
with a great latitude: active consideration of ideas events, new stories/coverage;
exploration of feelings, personal reactions or concerns; definition of
questions, and so on.
How do I use free writing?
At the beginning of class, allow 5 minutes for short freewriting
exercises like the ones proposed below. (The reason for the focus of these
questions is that none has a "right" or "wrong" answer, but is focused
on the student's own experience.) Ideally, allow students -- either in
pairs or in small groups or 3-4 -- to spend another 5 minutes talking
about what they have written, followed (if this is practical in your class)
by brief reports from each group to the rest of the students. Even if
no small-group discussion follows, this kind of exercise can help "clear
the air" or reduce stress so that students can concentrate more fully
on the coursework you will then be discussing.
The process is simple but should be followed exactly to produce the
best results. At the beginning of the exercise, tell the class:
Write NON-STOP for the next 5 minutes. I will tell you what you're
going to focus on in a minute. Do not lift your pen/pencil from the
page. If you run out of words/ideas, or "block" in any way, keep on
writing either copy the end of the last group of words, or write "Help,
help" or nonsense words until you get back on the track. Grammar, spelling,
and punctuation don't count -- nobody will ever see this, you can write
fragments, phrases, questions, complete sentences, poems, images anything
relevant. Do not censor any words, ideas, feeling, or questions that
come to mind. Put them all on paper however they come to you. This is
freewriting, not editing, so don't cross out anything or hold back on
things that seem "silly" or "stupid". I will tell you when to stop writing.
Then tell them the question you want them to respond to, and instruct
them to begin writing immediately. At the end of the 5 minutes, tell
them to stop writing and ask then to discuss in small groups or in pairs
what they have written about. They should not be asked to share what
they have actually written, just to talk about the thoughts that came
to them. These discussions can be limited to 5 minutes, and you can
simply instruct the groups to make sure that each person has a minute
or so to talk about what s/he wrote. If you wish, you can ask each group
to appoint a "recorder" who will report briefly to the whole
class what the responses were.
Suggested Freewiting Topics
- Where were you when you first heard about the outbreak of war? What
do you recall about your reactions?
- What are your personal worries or concerns about the crises?
- In what way(s) has the crisis affected you? (In any way, at any
level.)
- Which of your feelings or ideas has changed/remained the same?
- What do you find confusing about the war?
- How do you feel about a friend/relative who is or could be in the
New York, Washington or an area directly affected?
- What are your reactions to events on the campus?
- How are other people's reactions to the crisis affecting you?
- How have your thoughts changed in the past few weeks?
- What are you learning as the events in surrounding the tragedies
unfold?
- What are the most successful ways of coping you have found to deal
with the crisis and the feelings it brings up?
- What do you feel about a possible renewal of the draft? (Corollary
question: Do you think women should be included if the draft is revived?)
- What is your view of the amount of time your professors are spending
on this issue?
- How do things you learn in this class/field of study contribute
to your understanding of the situation?
- In what way(s) have you changed/not changed in reaction to the prospect
of war?
These are intended only as suggestions: you can use your own imagination,
intelligence, discretion, and common sense to make up questions of your
own.
Instructional Strategies
The following are suggestions for strategies you may wish to adopt
in your classrooms. Feel free to adapt them to your own needs and those
of your students.
Q. How do I enable students to express their concerns but still teach
my course?
- "Check-in" to determine whether the class is ready to go ahead with
the day's coursework (they may need or wish to spend a few minutes
on current events):
- Take 5 minutes for a discussion of their priorities (If they seem
to need time for discussion of current events, set a time-limit on
the discussion).
- Do a freewriting exercise (see above).
- At the end of class, ask students to submit, anonymously, questions
they may wish to discuss -- start the next class with a 5-minute discussion
of one or two of these questions.
- Devise bridges between their concerns and your class goals for the
day.
- Begin the class with small-group discussions of current events,
or concerns, asking each group to designate a recorder to report back
to the class.
- Assign out-of-class journals in which students can keep a record
of their responses, questions, and so on. Read and respond to what
they say but do not "comment on" or judge the content of
the journals, or grade them. You may want to use a check/check plus/check
minus system, recording that the journals have been submitted. Students
should know that the journals will "count" toward the course
grade.
Q. What changes could I make in my course design to allow for limited
discussion of current events?
- Without undercutting your course goals, restructure the time during
the semester. For example, the typical semester includes about 14
or 15 weeks of instruction. Consider that over the course of the semester
you might devote a weeks worth of attention to the events. If you
are comfortable doing so, you may want to spend time during the first
two class meetings discussing the war, contextualizing the discussion
if possible in the content of your discipline or the particular course.
Then, you might take shorter periods during several of the class periods
during the semester.
- If possible, resequence course materials so that early classes focus
on reading or lecture material that you can explicitly relate to the
crisis.
- Make a practice of stating explicitly the connections (conceptual,
ethical, procedural, or whatever) between your coursework and the
events.
- Rethink the way you allocate time in each class meeting, e.g., build
in time for impromptu writing about or discussion of the Gulf issues.
- Where the coursework makes this appropriate, design formal or informal
writing assignments that encourage students to form their own connections,
ask (and discuss) their own questions. Help them find ways to make
the connection between the things they learn in your class and "real
world" events.
Suggestions for Group Discussion
Q. If I choose to have group discussions, how do I encourage students
to act toward others with respect, tolerance, and appreciation of a
diversity of beliefs, feelings, and circumstances?
- At the outset of the course, you may find it useful to point out
to your classes that the students, faculty, staff and administrators
on this campus represent wide spectrum of beliefs, values, and circumstances.
Some of us have children, spouses, relatives or friends on active
duty or eligible for call-up. Some of us have family living in Afghanistan
or the Middle East where war may be waged, and may be finding it difficult
to maintain contact with them. Some of us strongly support the position
of the U.S., while others may not.
- You may find it beneficial to practice "preventive medicine", that
is, at the outset of a discussion, to set limits/ground-rules about
how you expect differences to be dealt with, or to specify the length
you will allow for discussions or for each speaker, or to state explicitly
that in the university we seek discussion, not hostile attacks.
- You may prefer to keep the focus of discussions on students and
their concerns about the crisis. It will help if you model respect,
tolerance, and appreciation of their right to hold and to articulate
what will be widely divergent perspectives. You may therefore want
to find ways of acknowledging or validating what each student says,
especially if someone voices an unpopular perspective.
- Listen carefully to what students say and encourage then to listen
to each other with great care.
- To show that you are listening to all viewpoints, you may want to
paraphrase as closely as possible what the speaker has said. You may
also want to encourage students to paraphrase each other's statements.
The goal in each case is to verify accuracy of interpretation without
judgment of what the speaker has said.
- Ask students to:
- Make "I" rather than "you" statements, e.g.,
"I am angry/worried/concerned about _________",
- Avoid big "they/them" or "you" statements (they
can sound and feel accusatory),
- Listen carefully and ask questions rather than respond declaratively
if they are in disagreement with something that is said.
- At the end of a discussion, you may find it helpful to summarize
the points of common concern or other commonalities that have arisen,
facility reminding your listeners that despite points of disagreement
they have shared feelings and thoughts.
- You may want to share with them copies of the
Principles of Conduct for a Multicultural University as a sense
of the kinds of values shared by many on campus. Do not use them,
inappropriately, as policies or rules but as a way to encourage them
to think about their values concerning how they wish to be treated
and how they wish to treat others.
Q. How should I respond if the students ask about my position or my
concerns with respect to the war?
A. There is no single or simple answer to this question - but it may
come up. You may want to prepare a response should the question be asked.
Aim to be flexible.
Promote communication, not confrontation.
Foster the development of respect, tolerance and understanding.
This exercise was designed by a group of SFSU faculty during the Persian Gulf conflict. It was rediscovered
by J. Gregory, English Department, and modified for use by OHR staff
for the current situation.
|